The Yankees current rotation would be untouchable if it was 2005. They would have an up and coming C.C. Sabathia, a prime Freddy Garcia, a 98 mph fastball out of A.J. Burnett and of course the American League Cy Young winner; Bartolo Colon.
Colon’s Cy Young year in 2005 was impressive, but his 21 wins were the stat that carried him to the award. He posted a 3.48 ERA with a 635 K/9, and a 3.91 xfip. xFIP??!?! What’s that you might ask? xFIP is “Expected Fielding Independent Pitching. This is an experimental stat that adjusts FIP and "normalizes" the home run component. Research has shown that home runs allowed are pretty much a function of flyballs allowed and home park, so xFIP is based on the average number of home allowed per outfield fly. Theoretically, this should be a better predictor of a pitcher's future ERA.” (
http://www.hardballtimes.com/main/statpages/glossary/)

Those stats are hardly Cy Young worthy compared to other winners of the past 10-20 years, but way back in 2005, all that mattered for the Cy Young was wins, so that explains Bartolo’s award winning season.However, after 2005, Colon never threw over 100 innings, and it appeared that Colon would never make a return to his Cy Young form. Until now and not one person could possibly say they saw this coming.
2011 has seen a 36 year old Bartolo Colon come out of nowhere, after not pitching in all of 2010, to become an above average starting pitcher. In 66+ innings this season, Colon owns a 3.77 ERA. It isn’t dominant, but his peripheral numbers indicate that his ERA should be even lower. Colon is striking batters out at a 8.40 K/9 rate. That’s two more strikeouts per nine innings than his Cy Young award winning year. What’s more impressive is his xFIP is at 2.91. A number that low shows that Colon has an ERA that is inflated by over a run. Doug Fister had a +1.50 differential between his ERA and xFIP and over the course of the 2010 season; his ERA was corrected to within .50 of his xFIP. It isn’t a sure thing that Colon’s ERA will drop, but it’s a rare case to have a pitcher continuing with a -1.20 difference between ERA and xFIP (or a +1.50, etc)

Colon’s bread and butter have always been in his stomach. I mean his ability to have good control in the strike zone and keep his walks to a minimum. In his Cy Young season, Colon had an excellent 1.74 BB/9 and in 2011 he’s kept that number low with a 2.04 BB/9. Colon has lost a full MPH on his fastball (92.7 to 91.7) from 2005, but he’s pounding the strike zone and most importantly; he’s missing bats. In ’05 he had a 4.5 WAR (lowest I could find by a CY winner). So far this year it’s at 1.3 and if he keeps this up, he’ll be more valuable than his Cy Young award winning season.
Everyone say it with me: BaaaaarrrrrrrTOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO!